It's half-term now, time for many parents to shove most of their work to one side and reintroduce themselves to their offspring. Me, I've taken the wee bairn back to the 'hood, which in my case is across the Atlantic in and around the storied Motor City, Detroit. And while you'd think 3,561 miles (according to the handy in-flight map) was enough distance between me and the economic pillage being wrought by the ConDems in Old Blighty, here staring me in the face is the future of UK arts and culture. Or at least, one potentially horrible version of it.
I speak of the travails that presently face the Detroit Symphony Orchestra, consistently ranked as one of the America's finest. The DSO was one of the earliest cultural products to roll off the philanthropic assembly line created by the US automakers that still make their home here. And therein lies the problem: the Big Three have been in decline for, well, as long as I can remember. As a result the DSO has fought off economic peril from every quarter: ticket sales sinking (because of high unemployment), sponsorship dwindling (because businesses are cutting back, shutting down, or moving out), and private endowment shrinking (because of bottom-dwelling interest rates and the need to dig into principal due to previously-mentioned reasons).
The upshot is that DSO management are asking its musicians to take a whopping 33% pay cut (and into the bargain, to give a few free public lessons to show good will.) The musicians, world-class in most cases, are having none of it: they thought the 22% pay cut they proposed was pain enough. And so, as of this writing, the music has stopped in Motown…at least, the classical kind.
What's worse is that most folks seem to think this is just fine. Detroit is a city in decline; why on Earth should it have a world-class symphony? This was essentially what a Wall Street Journal article said recently about the debacle. Such sentiments understandably provoked anger among DSO musicians…but not, sadly, among the city's general populous. Its economy still on the ropes (though improving) and its physical infrastructure in some quarters approaching post-apocalyptic, Detroit doesn't seem to have the energy to fight the erosion of its cultural provision. It's generally agreed that big cuts will happen, big players will leave, and the DSO will be reduced to a regional treasure, rather than a national one. Worse still, DSO's fate is also mooted for the city's world-class art gallery and national (if not quite world) class opera company. Thus does a city's decline, both real and in reputation, self-perpetuate.
Detroit's saga begs questions that communities across Britain should now be asking themselves as they stare down the massive retrenchment in the nation's cultural funding. What part of a community's pride and self-image is comprised of its cultural provision? How Big can your Society be, really, if theatres, museums, galleries, and arts organisations are priced out, closed down or radically scaled back?
If nothing else, the DSO saga gives the lie to the ConDem fantasy of a more robust cultural world through private funding. Ironically, Detroit's automakers this week are posting bumper profits again. But it takes time for profit to translate into munificence and therein lies the Achilles' Heel of privately-driven cultural funding, versus a system that supports the arts–which will always suffer commercially in hard times–as a matter of national principle. While the banks (and Detroit's auto industry) got zillions to keep from going belly-up, America has no public bail-out plan for its many dying galleries, museums, orchestras and arts companies. Even if Detroit's philanthropists cough up as they once did, it may be too late for the DSO and its sister institutions.
That said, at least the US government isn't actively seeking to wreck its cultural sector (yet). In Britain, the kind of stark choices facing Detroit are being aided and abetted by a slash-happy government clueless about the role of arts and culture in its own society. And so, we must ask the question. Which city here will be the first to face Detroit's bleak cultural future?
Posted via email from gregklerkx’s posterous